LOG ON
Username  Register free
 Forgot Password
Password
SEARCH

  
 
Today on GaydarNation
You are not logged in
Radioshow
Travel
Naples
Antwerp
A Passage To... Ibiza
Entertainment
On The Scene: Syke ‘n’ Sugarstarr
The A-Team
Beautiful Kate
Fun
Dykons: Sacha Parkinson
TW: Alexander Skarsgård
Soap Villain Quiz
Newsshow
Lifestyleshow
Personalsshow
Newest Blogs
Have Your Say
Police Online
My GaydarNation
What's New
Downloads
Competitions
E-Cards
Contact
Related Links
Gay Dating
Lesbian Dating
True Vision
Hard Cell
Drug & Alcohol Advice
Sex & Sexual Health
Positive Gay Guide
Terms & Conditions
Privacy Policy
Disclaimers
News
Trans Group Angry At Stonewall Award Nomination
17 Oct 2008
Related Articles
MBE For Gay Rights Campaigner And Tube Station Manager
FA Backs New Anti-Homophobia Campaign
Molly Ringwald Joins 'No To Prop 8' Campaign
AXM Magazine To Close
Indian Court Asks For Scientific Proof To Justify Gay Ban
Elton To Make 'HIV Musical' With Ben Stiller
HIV Trial Begins In The Netherlands
Ellen Makes TV Ad Against Prop 8
'Gay Tattoo' Vicar Says He Was Wrong
Catholic Bishop Threatens Own Adoption Agency
Trash Palace Moves East
Related Links
Queer Youth Network
Trans Youth Network
NUS LGBT Campaign

The Queer Youth Network has expressed its "concern and disappointment" at the nomination of Guardian journalist Julie Bindel for a Stonewall Award.

It comes following her arguments in recent articles that transsexuals are "damaged" by surgery and that transsexuality is an "unhelpful ideology" that leaves people worse off.

Earlier this year Bendel [pictured] was banned from speaking alongside the NUS LGBT Campaign as a result.

The Queer and Trans Youth Networks believe her views to be "upsetting and deeply offensive" and that the nomination could be damaging to some of the most vulnerable people within the trans community.

"We believe her views to be upsetting and deeply offensive to many sections of our diverse LGBT community and have concluded that such recognition could prove damaging to some of the most vulnerable people (including transgender, transsexual, gender-queer and intersex young people) who already face great hardship and discrimination due to their gender identity," the group said in a statement.

In an open letter addressed to "fellow members and supporters of our community" and copied to Ben Summerskill, the chief executive, Stonewall, the Queer Youth Network founder and director David Joseph Henry called into question the credibility of the Stonewall Awards themselves.

"I accept these nominations do not represent the views of Stonewall, which leads me puzzled as to who exactly they do represent," it says.

"Despite our dismay at the nomination of Julie Bindel I have tremendous respect for many of Stonewall's past accomplishments which have been supported by ourselves and many often unsung activists and advocates, it is these are the people who should in fact be receiving recognition."

"We will continue to lend our expertise and guidance to them through our involvement in Stonewall's Education for All coalition of which we are a member," it adds.

The group state that there needs to be a greater sense of unity between the "LGB" community which Stonewall is a part of and the extended Trans and Queer communities who it says Stonewall are not actively engaging with.

Trans Youth Network has produced a poster to compliment the existing resources offered by Education for All, in particular the 'Some People are Gay – Get Over it' posters produced by Stonewall.

The TYN's poster reads 'Some People are Transgender – and we're over it!' which is available to download from the Trans Youth Network website at http://www.transyouth.org

"By adding balance and reason to the debate which has been tainted by cruel and inaccurate perpetuated by Julie Bindel and individuals who subscribe to her inflammatory beliefs we hope to eradicate Transphobic attitudes both within the LGBT community and beyond," the Trans Youth Network said.

"Although we may not posses the same level of resources as Stonewall and the dominant figures who speak on our behalf, we believe the way to overcome further ignorance is to educate our communities, friends and families on the all too often ignored but critical issue of gender identity that affect us all," they add.

Author: Joanne Oatts
Read more by this author
User reviews
 
Be the first to review this item - click on WRITE A REVIEW